The book, too, vividly illustrates the sometimes harrowing consequences of concussions. Heads up to youth sports heads up cdc injury center. When postconcussion syndrome forced star nfl running back merril hoge into early. Sep 28, 2018 the debate over youth tackle football has become an extension of the countrys polarized politics, replete with references to the nanny state and charges of corporate negligence. Chris manages to write a book that gives a solid scientific explanation into post concussion syndrome and head concussions in general while remaining extremely reader friendly. Concussions from youth football pubmed central pmc. And his message is that tackle football is safe for children who want to play it. Book recommends no tackle football, soccer headers for u.
Hoge disputes research, proponent of tackle football for. Kids should not be allowed to play tackle football vox. Nov 16, 2019 so these are three of the biggest youth tackle football programs in marshall. May 11, 2018 there is a debate in our country about youth tackle football. Exnfl star merril hoge disputes any connection between football and the brain disease cte in his new book brainwashed 24 years after his.
In the longrunning debate over the safety of tackle football for children another voice has entered the fray. Aug 23, 2016 and by reducing players exposure to these impacts, concussions in youth football can be reduced. This model rule book rule book is provided to ayf members as a resource that may be used in connection. Nov 06, 2012 in my new book, concussions and our kids, which i coauthored with dr. In my new book, concussions and our kids, which i coauthored with dr. Hoge disputes research, proponent of tackle football for kids. He has told politicians that children should not play tackle football before they are teenagers. Concussions can occur with a blow to the head through helmet to helmet contact, and if undiagnosed and left untreated can lead to permanent brain damage.
When pop warner youth tackle football began, the youngest players were 15. Merril hoge calls fear around youth tackle football exaggerated merril hoge speaks out on misinformation regarding concussions merril hoge discusses his book brainwashed and what the cardinals should do with the number one overall pick. A guide for teaching safer football and preventing injuries written because of his tremendous passion for coaching youth sports, he wanted to educate parents and coaches on the potential longterm effects of concussions and other kinds of injuries due to illfitting equipment, and lack of education. According to, concussion rates for children under age 19 who play tackle football have doubled over the last decade, most occurring during practices. Book recommends no tackle football, soccer headers for u14. The book, too, vividly illustrates the sometimes harrowing consequences of. Until then, they should play flag football, where kids grab. Boston university has been publishing studies about concussions, and chronic traumatic encephalopathy cte for about the last 78 years which specifically outline the. Until tackle football is proven safe for the developing brain, we urgently recommend parents only enroll their children in flag and other nontackle versions of football before age 14. So these are three of the biggest youth tackle football programs in marshall. Cte in youth football is serious, but so was my sons coach.
Over football teams, travel from throughout the usa to kissimmee, florida, home to universal studios orlando, islands of adventure and disney world, to participate in weight protected, age protected, allstar, and instructional divisions to compete for the. Youth football concussion study criticizing limits on contact. As a former football player both in high school and for harvard university, nowinski knows just how common these injuries are. Three million american kids take part in tackle football programs, and research has largely focused on the longterm effects of concussions, a form of traumatic brain injury. Delaying the introduction of tackle football until 14 is not as radical as it may. Youth football and the national football league are light years apart, yet both face a growing public concern. Oct 24, 2016 football alters the brains of kids as young as 8. Marv cook, former hawkeye and nfl tight end and current head football coach, iowa city regina. Study shows concussions up 500% in youth sports one of the key findings from the poll is that there is widespread awareness of cte among respondents who identify themselves as sports fans. Youth football athletes are as young as 5 years in the united states, 18 leaving 3 years of concussion data out of the study by bakhos et al. Oct 01, 2006 the focus of this book is on football players and head concussions. Youth football tied to emotional issues in adulthood in. Study shows concussions up 500% in youth sports sports. A guide to teaching safer football and preventing injuries stresky, mary jo, jackson, alan isbn.
Would delaying tackle football until high school make players safer. Mar 12, 2018 children are suffering brain injuries from contact sportsand now parents are demanding action. There was a recent study released that has turned some heads in regards to where all the concussions come from in sports. People from inside the game itself are among the headlinemaking voices of caution. Aug 23, 2016 pop warner, the largest youth football program in the u. Debate on youth football and concussions medpage today. Age a factor in youth football concussion symptoms, treatment. In this jama pediatrics study appearing at the beginning of the month the investigators have concluded that american football practices were a major source of concussions for all three levels of participation studied youth, high school and collegiate. Dangerous kids football can be made safer the washington post. And by reducing players exposure to these impacts, concussions in youth football can be reduced. Sep 19, 2017 y outh football participation in the u. In the postwar united states, high school football was celebrated as a moral sport for young boys, one that promised and celebrated the creation of the honorable male citizen. Medical experts supported by the nfl and youth football organizations have disputed research linking brain damage to the head impacts absorbed by children who play tackle football.
Children are suffering brain injuries from contact sportsand. In concussions and our kids, a book we cowrote in 2012, we argue for children to defer playing tackle football until age 14. In concussions and our kids, a book we cowrote in 2012, we argue. Ui sports medicine offers a concussion clinic from 4 to 6 p. The better game for children is flag football in which kids grab flags rather than each. Dec 27, 20 youth football athletes are as young as 5 years in the united states, 18 leaving 3 years of concussion data out of the study by bakhos et al. The new study hoped to understand when football players aged 6 to 14 suffer the most head impacts. Concern about concussions has grown in recent years, prompting some parents to hold their child out of tackle football. The focus of this book is on football players and head concussions. I have had two concussions in my time playing football. When a football player suffers a concussion during a game or in practice, whether theyre a pro or a student, its serious business. Robert cantu, a clinical professor of neurosurgery at the boston university school of medicine, we make the case for delaying organized tackle football until kids are 14 years old. Age a factor in youth football concussion symptoms. Apr 02, 2018 houston matters tackle football and concussions.
More than 2,000 former nfl players are suing the league for not warning them about concussions. Youth football deemed generally safe from the data, lead author anthony kontos, assistant research director for the university of pittsburgh medical center upmc sports concussion program, and colleagues concluded that youth football is a generally safe activity with regard to concussions for children aged 812 years, particularly during practice. Aug 19, 2019 in concussions and our kids, a book we cowrote in 2012, we argue for children to defer playing tackle football until age 14. Concussions during games were most common in college players, averaging almost 4 per 1,000 games. Pop warner football is safer today than at any point in our history, thanks to mandated coaching education, greater awareness of concussions, a changing. Collegiate sports doctor discusses cte, concussions and tackle football standard posted. Robert cantu recommends restricting youth athletes under the age of 14 from playing tackle football, bodychecking in ice hockey, or heading soccer. The reality of how often it happens and the seriousness of not just short term effects, but long term as well are frightening. In one corner are those who argue that playing tackle football at an early age. Football alters the brains of kids as young as 8 the atlantic. Bill would ban tackle football for kids under 12 toms river, nj the bill is prompted by concerns about the longterm effects of concussions and repeated blows to the head on football players. Nj bill would ban tackle football for kids under 12 toms. Youth tackle football will be considered unthinkable 50 years from now i would know im a cte expert and former college football player.
Children are suffering brain injuries from contact sports. For more information on head concussions this book should be required reading for all coaches of youth sports and all parents who have children in any kind of contact sport. High schoolers are the most likely to suffer a concussion, with 46% of diagnosed concussions. In this book, kathleen bachynski offers the first history of youth tackle football and. Jul, 2016 those two months usually span almost the entire youth football season across the united states. May 03, 2016 concussions during games were most common in college players, averaging almost 4 per 1,000 games. Nov 08, 2018 on the first day the panthers worked on rugby tackling, in which the head is kept out of the play, i thought back to my first day of tackle football as a 9yearold for the marshall mich. The heads up initiative provides important information on preventing, recognizing, and responding to a concussion. There is a debate in our country about youth tackle football. To help ensure the health and safety of young athletes, cdc developed the heads up concussion in youth sports initiative to offer information about concussions to coaches, parents, and athletes involved in youth sports. Kids who start playing tackle football before the age of 12 are at much higher risk of developing behavioral and emotional troubles as adults, according to a. Concussions can occur with a blow to the head through helmet to helmet contact, and if undiagnosed and left untreated can lead to.
In this book, kathleen bachynski offers the first history of youth tackle football and debates over its safety. Jul 20, 2016 study shows concussions up 500% in youth sports one of the key findings from the poll is that there is widespread awareness of cte among respondents who identify themselves as sports fans. Dec 19, 2016 he has told politicians that children should not play tackle football before they are teenagers. Collegiate sports doctor discusses cte, concussions and. Professor takes on youth football the muhlenberg weekly. The attention being given to concussions is important. The american youth football national championships features the largest youth football tournament in the world. Football can damage kids brains even if they dont get.
For a player who starts tackle football at age 7, that threshold can be reached by age 18 if he averages 250 hits a seasona number. Boston university has been publishing studies about concussions, and chronic traumatic encephalopathy cte for about the last 78 years which specifically outline the dangers of football. Oct 24, 2016 three million american kids take part in tackle football programs, and research has largely focused on the longterm effects of concussions, a form of traumatic brain injury. The debate over youth tackle football has become an extension of the countrys polarized politics, replete with references to the nanny state and charges of corporate negligence. Nov 26, 2018 exnfl star merril hoge disputes any connection between football and the brain disease cte in his new book brainwashed 24 years after his own career was ended by concussions. Some things to consider for kids who do play football. They worry their child might develop chronic traumatic encephalopathy cte, the progressive brain disease diagnosed in some of their football heroes. Those two months usually span almost the entire youth football season across the united states. Youth football concussion study criticizing limits on. Pop warner, the largest youth football program in the u.
Robert cantu recommends restricting youthathletes under the age of 14 from playing tackle football, bodychecking in ice hockey, or. Based on my 30 years of experience in the sports insurance niche and the potential for brain injury litigation, i would not want to be a board member or staff member involved with a youth tackle football organization that did not have an effective, formallyadopted and fullyimplemented written concussionbrain injury risk management program. Until tackle football is proven safe for the developing brain, we urgently recommend parents only enroll their children in flag and other non tackle versions of football before age 14. Youth football tied to emotional issues in adulthood. Politicians push to ban tackle in youth football leagues. Nfl players, eventually led to the book and later the 2015 film, concussion.
675 216 548 873 36 1182 982 424 1537 55 1549 382 381 1092 273 1434 1482 837 360 720 346 785 804 364 446 1322 1317 1074 784 240 103 995 1262 928 1234 974 607 877 109 505 872 88 1475 1079 797 612 269